A GW-n az egyik rajongótársunk irónikusan összegyűjtötte, hogy mitől lehet jó egy SG rész:
WHAT THE PTB MUST DO TO SATISFY ABSOLUTELY EVERYBODY ON EVERY EPISODE:
1. Don’t ever refer back to events that happened in prior episodes, â€cause then you’re just â€recycling plots’ – but make sure you mention things that have happened before, for continuity.
2. Make sure there’s lots of interaction between the characters in every episode – but there has to be lots of action in every episode or it’s boring.
3. The characters have to grow and develop all the time – but they can’t do anything too new because that’s not consistent with how they were before.
4. Every CGI pic has to be perfect – but don’t use all the budget on CGI because then the show has nothing left for story.
5. Don’t let Sam Carter talk about thing that happened to her before she came to Atlantis, â€cause that’s just pulling SG-1 into SGA – but make sure she mentions any prior events that connect, because she’s ignoring the past if she doesn’t.
6. Every space battle must be huge and full of action – but it can’t take too long or it gets old.
7. Every story must be connected to the â€season arc’ – but we can’t have any story not started and finished in the same episode, since unanswered questions are too annoying, and 2 or 3 parters are slow.
8. You must mention lost characters at every opportunity, to prove that you remember them – but you can’t talk about them all the time, because then you’re not moving on.
9. The main characters must have more to do in each episode, â€cause they’re the reason we watch – but the supporting characters must never be set aside just because they don’t fit in the plot for this episode; they have to be shown always.
10. Related to the above, each character must have priority in at least one episode per season – but you must not EVER skip having lots of the other characters in EVERY episode.
11. New characters mustn’t do anything differently from the characters they’ve replaced, because the original characters were perfect for their places – but they mustn’t be carbon copies, or there was no need to change characters in the first place.
12. Don’t ever use any idea (or even a part of an idea) that’s ever been done before (whether in SG-1 or any other show EVER) because that’s ripping off old plots – but any idea that’s completely new has no precedent, therefore doesn’t fit in to canon.
13. The characters must be completely close to each other, like a family, and willing to do anything to back each other up – but there must be constant conflict between them, because without internal conflict there’s no drama. External conflict doesn’t count.
14. Every tiny bit of information must be brought out in dialogue or scenes; never leave anything to the imagination of the watcher, even if it makes every episode 3 hours long, because that’s copping out and leaving plot holes – but you must not beat us to death with nitpicky data and details of information, because we’re not idiots.
15. Don't do anything controversial, since someone is going to be bothered by it - but you must be edgy and dark, because this is SGA!
16. And last but not least, John Sheppard must take an â€oath of celibacy’ a la Lt Ilia of the Deltans in Star Trek: the Motion Picture, since it’s completely obvious that all he has to do is be in the same scene with a woman and he’s thinking about nothing but sex – in spite of the fact that by his own words he â€never sees this coming’.
Additional points made, and those who made them:
17. Kill off the characters fans wail and scream about in dislike - but then bring them back to life to satisfy the fans who wail and scream when their favorite characters are bumped off for the sake of ratings (prion)
18. On the opposite side, kill off popular characters to ensure a real sense of danger - but make sure you bring the characters back to ensure the show is science-fiction and therefore no one ever really dies.(jackie)
19. Reset buttons are bad, don't ever use them; unless you want to bring back a dead character that fans loved, then it doesn't matter even if you pull a Dallas. (pg15)
20. Characters should have long term romantic relationships because it's unrealistic if they don't – but if they do have long term romantic relationships, though, it's turning the show into a soap opera and sci-fi isn't meant to be a soap opera.(ciannwn)
21. We need more technology like ZPM's and ships – but not so much that we become too advanced.(jelgate)
22. Make sure the stargate appears in almost every ep – but also make sure we use the ships most of the time.(jackie)
23. These people are the best of the best; that's why they were chosen for this mission. Thus, they should be perfect at what they do and never make stupid mistakes. But, don't make them too perfect, or else they'll be Mary Sues/Gary Stus. (pg15)
24. Stop bringing in hot babes as guest stars; they're just there to appeal to the young male audience. However, don't ever stop bringing in buff guy guest stars, because...they're good actors, or something. (pg15)
25. Related to above: stop putting our female main characters in tight and/or revealing clothes, because that's fanservice for the young males. But, make sure to show all the hot guys' chests and/or have them be barefoot, because that's totally adding to the story. (pg15)
26. Utilize Google so you don’t put glaring errors on the show – but you can't limit yourself to current science levels, because that negates all the alien advances. (prion/raven56)
27. Related to above: Make sure to stick to established science and never assume that the piece of alien technology being handled can do things our limited knowledge can't comprehend, because it's SCIENCE fiction. On the other hand, be imaginative and think up new technologies that can do cool things, because this is science FICTION. (pg15)
28. Make sure to spend as many episodes exploring the city as possible, as it's Stargate ATLANTIS. But, make sure to go offworld and explore new worlds as much as possible, since it's called STARGATE Atlantis. (pg15/Raven56)
Lehet érdemes lenne lefordítani, mert én egy csomót nevettem rajta, hogy mennyire igaz ránk.
WHAT THE PTB MUST DO TO SATISFY ABSOLUTELY EVERYBODY ON EVERY EPISODE:
1. Don’t ever refer back to events that happened in prior episodes, â€cause then you’re just â€recycling plots’ – but make sure you mention things that have happened before, for continuity.
2. Make sure there’s lots of interaction between the characters in every episode – but there has to be lots of action in every episode or it’s boring.
3. The characters have to grow and develop all the time – but they can’t do anything too new because that’s not consistent with how they were before.
4. Every CGI pic has to be perfect – but don’t use all the budget on CGI because then the show has nothing left for story.
5. Don’t let Sam Carter talk about thing that happened to her before she came to Atlantis, â€cause that’s just pulling SG-1 into SGA – but make sure she mentions any prior events that connect, because she’s ignoring the past if she doesn’t.
6. Every space battle must be huge and full of action – but it can’t take too long or it gets old.
7. Every story must be connected to the â€season arc’ – but we can’t have any story not started and finished in the same episode, since unanswered questions are too annoying, and 2 or 3 parters are slow.
8. You must mention lost characters at every opportunity, to prove that you remember them – but you can’t talk about them all the time, because then you’re not moving on.
9. The main characters must have more to do in each episode, â€cause they’re the reason we watch – but the supporting characters must never be set aside just because they don’t fit in the plot for this episode; they have to be shown always.
10. Related to the above, each character must have priority in at least one episode per season – but you must not EVER skip having lots of the other characters in EVERY episode.
11. New characters mustn’t do anything differently from the characters they’ve replaced, because the original characters were perfect for their places – but they mustn’t be carbon copies, or there was no need to change characters in the first place.
12. Don’t ever use any idea (or even a part of an idea) that’s ever been done before (whether in SG-1 or any other show EVER) because that’s ripping off old plots – but any idea that’s completely new has no precedent, therefore doesn’t fit in to canon.
13. The characters must be completely close to each other, like a family, and willing to do anything to back each other up – but there must be constant conflict between them, because without internal conflict there’s no drama. External conflict doesn’t count.
14. Every tiny bit of information must be brought out in dialogue or scenes; never leave anything to the imagination of the watcher, even if it makes every episode 3 hours long, because that’s copping out and leaving plot holes – but you must not beat us to death with nitpicky data and details of information, because we’re not idiots.
15. Don't do anything controversial, since someone is going to be bothered by it - but you must be edgy and dark, because this is SGA!
16. And last but not least, John Sheppard must take an â€oath of celibacy’ a la Lt Ilia of the Deltans in Star Trek: the Motion Picture, since it’s completely obvious that all he has to do is be in the same scene with a woman and he’s thinking about nothing but sex – in spite of the fact that by his own words he â€never sees this coming’.
Additional points made, and those who made them:
17. Kill off the characters fans wail and scream about in dislike - but then bring them back to life to satisfy the fans who wail and scream when their favorite characters are bumped off for the sake of ratings (prion)
18. On the opposite side, kill off popular characters to ensure a real sense of danger - but make sure you bring the characters back to ensure the show is science-fiction and therefore no one ever really dies.(jackie)
19. Reset buttons are bad, don't ever use them; unless you want to bring back a dead character that fans loved, then it doesn't matter even if you pull a Dallas. (pg15)
20. Characters should have long term romantic relationships because it's unrealistic if they don't – but if they do have long term romantic relationships, though, it's turning the show into a soap opera and sci-fi isn't meant to be a soap opera.(ciannwn)
21. We need more technology like ZPM's and ships – but not so much that we become too advanced.(jelgate)
22. Make sure the stargate appears in almost every ep – but also make sure we use the ships most of the time.(jackie)
23. These people are the best of the best; that's why they were chosen for this mission. Thus, they should be perfect at what they do and never make stupid mistakes. But, don't make them too perfect, or else they'll be Mary Sues/Gary Stus. (pg15)
24. Stop bringing in hot babes as guest stars; they're just there to appeal to the young male audience. However, don't ever stop bringing in buff guy guest stars, because...they're good actors, or something. (pg15)
25. Related to above: stop putting our female main characters in tight and/or revealing clothes, because that's fanservice for the young males. But, make sure to show all the hot guys' chests and/or have them be barefoot, because that's totally adding to the story. (pg15)
26. Utilize Google so you don’t put glaring errors on the show – but you can't limit yourself to current science levels, because that negates all the alien advances. (prion/raven56)
27. Related to above: Make sure to stick to established science and never assume that the piece of alien technology being handled can do things our limited knowledge can't comprehend, because it's SCIENCE fiction. On the other hand, be imaginative and think up new technologies that can do cool things, because this is science FICTION. (pg15)
28. Make sure to spend as many episodes exploring the city as possible, as it's Stargate ATLANTIS. But, make sure to go offworld and explore new worlds as much as possible, since it's called STARGATE Atlantis. (pg15/Raven56)
Lehet érdemes lenne lefordítani, mert én egy csomót nevettem rajta, hogy mennyire igaz ránk.
1. Epizódtémában nem kérdezünk letöltési lehetőségről! Az Abydos Gate NEM warez oldal.
2. Epizódtémában nem kérdezünk a feliratról, tehát nem sürgetjük és nem teszünk rá megjegyzést!
3. Előremutató információkat (= spoiler) nem írunk be az epizódok témáiba!
Fórumszabályzat!
2. Epizódtémában nem kérdezünk a feliratról, tehát nem sürgetjük és nem teszünk rá megjegyzést!
3. Előremutató információkat (= spoiler) nem írunk be az epizódok témáiba!
Fórumszabályzat!

Érdekesek az elvárások valóban.
Anno én is filóztam valami ilyesmit, persze sosem írtam le... Zseniális, és a szöveg nagy részét kvázi akármelyik sorozatra lehet applikálni.
Tényleg remekül adja vissza a rajongói tábor ezerirányú kívánságait.