2007-10-28 18:55
Nem hiszem el, hogy még senki nem nyitott neki topicot. Pedig (bocs Nefi) sokkal többet szerepel mint Lorne, és ezerszer jobb színész Jason Momománál. Mostanában elég sokat foglalkoztam vele, mert rábukkantam GW a vele foglalkozó topicokra. Valaki nagyon jól leírta, mért is olyan nagyszerű karakter. Beteszem ide andolul spoilerben, hogy aki akarja, olvassa el, és majd le is fordítom, csak az nem megy egyről a kettőre. Van benne egy kis íróanyázás is a végén, de sztem ez természetes, miután egy ilyen nagyszerű karaktert írak ki. Enjoy!
Spoiler!
Instead of being the usual stereotype one often finds on TV, especially in supporting roles, since these are mostly given much less thought than the leads or regulars of the show, this time it was completely different. Beckett has been a strong and very interesting character from the beginning. And to be frank, after watching 'Rising' I never would have guessed that the character of Carson Beckett wasn't meant to be a regular. After all he was definitely front and centre in the pilot episode. His endearing fright of ancient technology, which wasn't exactly eased after the incident with the drone and Major Sheppard's helicopter, the lovely Scottish accent, the way he treated everybody and cared for the others, then how he stood his ground against both Bates and Summner, who wanted to make him hurry with the medical supplies, the originality and power with which the performance came across simply blew me away. Aided by the breathtaking and heartwarming portrayal by Paul McGillion, I immediately realized that this character was someone very special, someone who was way above average male characters. Actually, it's been the first time I head over heals fell for a TV character. The kindness, compassion and sensitivity of Carson Beckett won my heart within the blink of an eye.
I think this kind of character was unprecedended as a male persona, especially since it stood in complete contrast with the characterizations of Sheppard and McKay. While John and Rodney were a hurricane with flippant, arrogant and snarky behaviour, together with Elizabeth, Carson was the calming presence, the one who never lost it during a medical emergency and who was the strong, solid rock who everybody could fall back upon.
Through this compassion and wholehearted wish to treat everybody to his best knowledge and conscience, even enemies, Carson Beckett soon became the moral core of the expedition. When everybody seemed to be concerned about tactics and advantages in a war, Carson had the people in mind. He never measured success by the battles won or lost, but by the casualties on both sides. Beckett truly lived up to his credo of "Do no harm!"
And although it is highly arguable whether inventing the retrovirus in the first place was a sensible decision or not, it mirrored how desperately Carson believed that once the Wraith weren't any longer dependent on feeding upon humans, it was only a small step to establishing a truce and eventually peace. Obviously his good intentions backfired on the good doc BIG TIME and in 'Misbegotten' he dearly paid for his "folly". But even though everybody but Ronon supported the decision on what to do with the former Wraith, Beckett was the ONLY one who treated the newly humans as humans, while Sheppard hardly concealed his contempt for the ex-Wraith and Ronon didn't even bother to try and do so. The Scot valiantly stood his ground against both Ronon and John when they demanded him to leave the turned Wraith to their own fate instead of tending to them any longer. Then after having to realize how horribly wrong he was in respect with trying to find a "cure" for being a Wraith, Carson never tried to belittle his role in the disaster or deny his responsibility for the failure.
Plus, I admired how he was never ashamed of showing his feelings openly. Especially men are usually considered weak for this sort of thing, Beckett even had to face Rodney's scorn from time to time for being so emotional. Yet, this didn't bother the lovely Scot the least bit. He was strong enough to take the high road and let it pass. Even though he often evoked the impression of being easily intimidated, Carson Beckett had an inner strength that even shone through when he was supposedly weak.
All these weaknesses, strengths, flaws, his integrity and fierce loyalty made Dr Carson Beckett a very complex but thoroughly lovable and unique character. It is truly a shame for TPTB to off such an incredibly original character who is liked by the vast majority of fans. I think the dimension of the protest is testament to how dearly beloved the character of Carson really is!
I think this kind of character was unprecedended as a male persona, especially since it stood in complete contrast with the characterizations of Sheppard and McKay. While John and Rodney were a hurricane with flippant, arrogant and snarky behaviour, together with Elizabeth, Carson was the calming presence, the one who never lost it during a medical emergency and who was the strong, solid rock who everybody could fall back upon.
Through this compassion and wholehearted wish to treat everybody to his best knowledge and conscience, even enemies, Carson Beckett soon became the moral core of the expedition. When everybody seemed to be concerned about tactics and advantages in a war, Carson had the people in mind. He never measured success by the battles won or lost, but by the casualties on both sides. Beckett truly lived up to his credo of "Do no harm!"
And although it is highly arguable whether inventing the retrovirus in the first place was a sensible decision or not, it mirrored how desperately Carson believed that once the Wraith weren't any longer dependent on feeding upon humans, it was only a small step to establishing a truce and eventually peace. Obviously his good intentions backfired on the good doc BIG TIME and in 'Misbegotten' he dearly paid for his "folly". But even though everybody but Ronon supported the decision on what to do with the former Wraith, Beckett was the ONLY one who treated the newly humans as humans, while Sheppard hardly concealed his contempt for the ex-Wraith and Ronon didn't even bother to try and do so. The Scot valiantly stood his ground against both Ronon and John when they demanded him to leave the turned Wraith to their own fate instead of tending to them any longer. Then after having to realize how horribly wrong he was in respect with trying to find a "cure" for being a Wraith, Carson never tried to belittle his role in the disaster or deny his responsibility for the failure.
Plus, I admired how he was never ashamed of showing his feelings openly. Especially men are usually considered weak for this sort of thing, Beckett even had to face Rodney's scorn from time to time for being so emotional. Yet, this didn't bother the lovely Scot the least bit. He was strong enough to take the high road and let it pass. Even though he often evoked the impression of being easily intimidated, Carson Beckett had an inner strength that even shone through when he was supposedly weak.
All these weaknesses, strengths, flaws, his integrity and fierce loyalty made Dr Carson Beckett a very complex but thoroughly lovable and unique character. It is truly a shame for TPTB to off such an incredibly original character who is liked by the vast majority of fans. I think the dimension of the protest is testament to how dearly beloved the character of Carson really is!


Beckett mégis csak főszereplő (volt).
De tudom, hogy visszatér, alig várom a napot.
, amelyik túlnőtt azon, hogy mellékszereplő legyen. Ezért lett talán főszereplő a második évadban, és ezért tört ki kisebbfajta hisztéria az USA-ban, amikor meghalasztották.